Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The 21st Century Salonnière's avatar

Not sure if it’s just my app, but this looks as if it might have been truncated at “crisis at the border”?

Re “You have the person whose great-grandmother came from Argentina, but has never visited Latin America, and does not speak Spanish, lumped into the exact same category as a Guatemalan who just crossed the U.S. border.”

Yes. And the former is now encouraged to embrace their “diversity,” call themselves “Latinx” and claim scholarships, admissions slots, or job offers, despite perhaps not really needing the help.

Our efforts at promoting diversity should move beyond these ethnic labels and focus more on the individuals -- especially their social class, which might even identify some disadvantaged “white” people as needing some help or opportunities.

But as to the main point: I agree -- labels or names should come organically from the groups themselves. I’d gladly change what I call “Latino / Latina” people ten more times, if the request came from people themselves expressing a preferences.

But the Latinx thing is an elite contrived invention, just another shibboleth to determine whether one is in the select club of people who know the very latest things.

Unfortunately, knowing the very latest things is completely divorced from any real-world efforts to help people, regardless of the labels you paste on them.

The left needs to reassess what exactly it values. Trappings, labels, appearances, tests? Or actions?

Expand full comment
Nicky McCatty's avatar

Really? [ !! ]

I just spent 15 minutes trying to find a way to finish one article. Suggestion: think up a subscription model that does more than repeat the fallacy that only rich read people think & read. I’m a senior, I’ve spent the past 4 years giving my 98-year-old mother end of life care, while also trying to recover from my own life threatening illnesses. And you’re demanding $5 monthly, to finish reading the first article I’ve ever read in your pub?

Talk about class divide. You might have succeeded in committing a new subscriber, instead you’ve ticked me off. Your Commitment Crew needs to invent a better idea….

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts